Methodology
Rent vs Own Equipment Comparison methodology
Educational only: Business decision support, not accounting, tax or legal advice.
Privacy: Calculations run locally; Margin101 does not receive your commercial inputs.
Update policy: Reviewed when formulas or official dependencies change.
Scope: Market-neutral small-business planning using your own assumptions.
1. Formulas and units
rentCostExTax = rental fixed cost + rental cost per period ร expected use periodsWhere
- expectedUsePeriods
- Expected use periods (whole use periods)Source: Business record
- rentalFixedCostExTax
- Rental fixed cost (currency units/comparison horizon, ex tax)Source: Business record
- rentalCostPerPeriodExTax
- Rental cost per period (currency units/use period, ex tax)Source: Business record
- rentCostExTax
- Total rental cost (currency units, ex tax)Source: Calculated output
ownCostExTax = purchase price โ residual value + ownership cost per period ร expected use periodsWhere
- expectedUsePeriods
- Expected use periods (whole use periods)Source: Business record
- purchasePriceExTax
- Purchase price (currency units/purchased asset, ex tax)Source: Business record
- residualValueExTax
- Residual value (currency units/purchased asset at comparison-horizon end, ex tax)Source: Business record
- ownershipCostPerPeriodExTax
- Ownership cost per period (currency units/use period, ex tax)Source: Business record
- ownCostExTax
- Total ownership cost (currency units, ex tax)Source: Calculated output
crossoverPeriods = ceiling((purchase price โ residual value โ rental fixed cost) รท (rental cost per period โ ownership cost per period)) when rental period cost is higherWhere
- rentalFixedCostExTax
- Rental fixed cost (currency units/comparison horizon, ex tax)Source: Business record
- rentalCostPerPeriodExTax
- Rental cost per period (currency units/use period, ex tax)Source: Business record
- purchasePriceExTax
- Purchase price (currency units/purchased asset, ex tax)Source: Business record
- residualValueExTax
- Residual value (currency units/purchased asset at comparison-horizon end, ex tax)Source: Business record
- ownershipCostPerPeriodExTax
- Ownership cost per period (currency units/use period, ex tax)Source: Business record
- rentCostExTax
- Total rental cost (currency units, ex tax)Source: Calculated output
- ownCostExTax
- Total ownership cost (currency units, ex tax)Source: Calculated output
- crossoverPeriods
- Crossover use periods (whole use periods)Source: Calculated output
Money inputs and outputs use the currency selected in the scenario without changing the canonical methodology. Rates, margins, utilisation and buffers are entered as percentages and converted to decimal values for calculation.
2. Worked example
Input assumptions
The rows below come directly from the exact engine using the visible default fixture.
- Expected use periods
- 20 whole use periods
- Rental fixed cost
- 0 currency units/comparison horizon, ex tax
- Rental cost per period
- 500 currency units/use period, ex tax
- Purchase price
- 8,000 currency units/purchased asset, ex tax
- Residual value
- 2,000 currency units/purchased asset at comparison-horizon end, ex tax
- Ownership cost per period
- 100 currency units/use period, ex tax
Calculation and outputs
Total rental cost
rentCostExTax = rental fixed cost + rental cost per period ร expected use periods- Expected use periods
- 20 whole use periods
- Rental fixed cost
- 0 currency units/comparison horizon, ex tax
- Rental cost per period
- 500 currency units/use period, ex tax
- Ownership cost per period
- 100 currency units/use period, ex tax
- Total ownership cost
- 8,000 currency units, ex tax
- Crossover use periods
- 15 whole use periods
Engine result: 10,000 currency units, ex tax
Total ownership cost
ownCostExTax = purchase price โ residual value + ownership cost per period ร expected use periods- Expected use periods
- 20 whole use periods
- Rental fixed cost
- 0 currency units/comparison horizon, ex tax
- Rental cost per period
- 500 currency units/use period, ex tax
- Purchase price
- 8,000 currency units/purchased asset, ex tax
- Residual value
- 2,000 currency units/purchased asset at comparison-horizon end, ex tax
- Ownership cost per period
- 100 currency units/use period, ex tax
- Total rental cost
- 10,000 currency units, ex tax
- Crossover use periods
- 15 whole use periods
Engine result: 8,000 currency units, ex tax
Crossover use periods
crossoverPeriods = ceiling((purchase price โ residual value โ rental fixed cost) รท (rental cost per period โ ownership cost per period)) when rental period cost is higher- Rental fixed cost
- 0 currency units/comparison horizon, ex tax
- Rental cost per period
- 500 currency units/use period, ex tax
- Purchase price
- 8,000 currency units/purchased asset, ex tax
- Residual value
- 2,000 currency units/purchased asset at comparison-horizon end, ex tax
- Ownership cost per period
- 100 currency units/use period, ex tax
- Total rental cost
- 10,000 currency units, ex tax
- Total ownership cost
- 8,000 currency units, ex tax
Engine result: 15 whole use periods
Example
The rows below come directly from the exact engine using the visible default fixture.
- Total rental cost
- 10,000.00
- Total ownership cost
- 8,000.00
- Lower-cost option
- Own
- Crossover use periods
- 15
The exact engine-derived outputs are shown in the labelled rows below.
Interpretation
Compare options on the same whole-use-period horizon; ownership cost is not only the purchase price.
3. Validation and boundary checks
- All values must be finite and remain inside the visible input boundaries.
- All money values use one consistent ex-tax basis and period.
- Rates must remain inside their engine-owned boundaries.
- Expected use periods must be a whole non-negative number and residual value cannot exceed purchase price.
- Crossover is unavailable when rental cost per period does not exceed ownership cost per period.
- Expected use periods minimum
expectedUsePeriods โฅ 0 whole use periodsโ A lower value is rejected before calculation.- Expected use periods maximum
expectedUsePeriods โค 100,000,000 whole use periodsโ A higher value is rejected before calculation.- Rental fixed cost minimum
rentalFixedCostExTax โฅ 0 currency units/comparison horizon, ex taxโ A lower value is rejected before calculation.- Rental fixed cost maximum
rentalFixedCostExTax โค 10,000,000 currency units/comparison horizon, ex taxโ A higher value is rejected before calculation.- Rental cost per period minimum
rentalCostPerPeriodExTax โฅ 0 currency units/use period, ex taxโ A lower value is rejected before calculation.- Rental cost per period maximum
rentalCostPerPeriodExTax โค 10,000,000 currency units/use period, ex taxโ A higher value is rejected before calculation.- Purchase price minimum
purchasePriceExTax โฅ 0 currency units/purchased asset, ex taxโ A lower value is rejected before calculation.- Purchase price maximum
purchasePriceExTax โค 10,000,000 currency units/purchased asset, ex taxโ A higher value is rejected before calculation.- Residual value minimum
residualValueExTax โฅ 0 currency units/purchased asset at comparison-horizon end, ex taxโ A lower value is rejected before calculation.- Residual value maximum
residualValueExTax โค 10,000,000 currency units/purchased asset at comparison-horizon end, ex taxโ A higher value is rejected before calculation.- Ownership cost per period minimum
ownershipCostPerPeriodExTax โฅ 0 currency units/use period, ex taxโ A lower value is rejected before calculation.- Ownership cost per period maximum
ownershipCostPerPeriodExTax โค 10,000,000 currency units/use period, ex taxโ A higher value is rejected before calculation.
4. Assumptions and source classification
- All hours, utilisation, costs, rates and recovery targets are supplied by the user.
- Money values use one consistent ex-tax basis.
- No provider fee, jurisdiction, benchmark or demand forecast is embedded.
- Raw engine precision is retained until display.
This comparison calculator has no current policy-data dependency. Its commercial assumptions are user supplied. Registered family-level regression suites exercise the shared business-logic engine and worked-result reconciliation.
5. Limitations
- Results depend on the completeness and classification of the entered business records.
- The planner does not forecast demand, utilisation, supplier terms or project outcomes.
- This is educational business decision support rather than accounting, tax, legal or financial advice.
- The comparison uses undiscounted entered costs and does not predict resale value, utilisation, downtime or financing terms.
This is educational decision support, not tax, accounting, legal or financial advice. Check the treatment of your actual transactions under the rules that apply to your business and seek qualified advice where appropriate.
6. Update and evidence policy
Registered family-level suites test formula invariants and example reconciliation; the release ledger records that coverage without claiming a separate oracle for every line of public copy. There is no official threshold or benchmark to refresh for this comparison calculator. Commercial inputs remain user-supplied because they vary by business and contract.
Change history
- : Initial public release of the Rent vs Own Equipment planner and methodology.
Related reading
Guides to interpret the decision and its assumptions.
- Own Vehicle vs Third-Party Carrier
Compare owned and contracted delivery using aligned fixed, variable, capacity and service assumptions.
Read guide